The Most Dangerous Intersections in New York
Under no-fault IME New York rules, your no-fault carrier can require a medical examination to decide whether to start or continue paying your benefits. The carrier chooses and pays the examiner. If you received a scheduling letter, you should attend, because failure to attend no-fault IME appointments may result in denial of all no-fault benefits for the accident. If your benefits are denied after an exam, you can challenge the denial through arbitration or in court.
You must attend an IME whenever the carrier properly asks. The mandatory no-fault policy language requires you to submit to an exam “when, and as often as” the company may reasonably require. The request can come early in a claim or months into treatment. The carrier may also request more than one exam.
Greenspan & Greenspan Injury Lawyers can review your exam notice before the appointment, request the report underlying the denial, and work with your treating doctors to prepare a response. Our attorneys can also pursue your injury claim against the at-fault driver. Contact Greenspan & Greenspan Injury Lawyers for a free consultation in English or Spanish before your exam date or as soon as a denial arrives.
Who Picks the Doctor, and What Rules Must the Insurer Follow?
Your policy lets the insurer choose who examines you. In an independent medical exam ordered by no-fault NY carriers, that person does not have to be a medical doctor. A New York appeals court has rejected the argument that a physician must perform every exam. The purpose of the exam is to help the insurer evaluate your claim, not to provide you with medical care.
The insurer still has to follow the rules:
- Place and time. The exam must be held at a place and time reasonably convenient to you, in a facility properly equipped for it.
- Reimbursement. When it schedules the exam, the insurer must tell you that you will be reimbursed for lost earnings and reasonable transportation costs.
- Timing. The following deadlines generally apply when the exam is requested as additional verification of a claim. The request must be sent within 15 business days of receiving the verification forms, and the exam must be scheduled within 30 calendar days of receiving them.
- No early stoppage. The insurer may not interrupt benefits while waiting to examine you, unless you or your attorney caused the delay. It may stop paying if it has information that “clearly demonstrates” you are no longer disabled.
These protections have limits. A New York appeals court has held that the timing rules do not apply when exam notices go out before the insurer receives the claims. A 2001 state insurance department opinion also found no minimum notice period. A letter that arrives only days before the exam is therefore not automatically invalid, although an arbitrator or court can decide whether the timing was reasonable.
What Is the Real Cost of a Failure to Attend No-Fault IME Appointments?
Attendance is a condition precedent to coverage, which means the insurer’s duty to pay depends on it. When a claimant misses properly scheduled exams, a New York appeals court has treated no-fault coverage for the accident as void from the start. In those cases, the insurer may deny all claims back to the accident date, even outside the usual 30-day deadline. The insurer does not have to prove you missed the exam on purpose. A missed exam can also affect every claim from the accident, not just one bill.
A missed date is not automatically fatal, however. To win on this defense, the insurer must prove that it requested the exams under the required procedures and time frames and that you did not appear. In one 2022 decision, a New York appeals court ruled against an insurer because the record did not show that it had met those deadlines. Courts have also applied a 10-calendar-day follow-up rule after a missed exam, and many reported cases involve two missed appointments. Even so, treat every appointment as the one that counts.
If you cannot make the date, take these steps before the appointment:
- Call the number on the notice and ask to reschedule,
- Send a short email or letter that states your request and explains why you cannot attend, and
- Keep a copy of what you sent and any new date you receive.
Do not skip an exam because the letter looks wrong. Under New York’s no-fault rules, a minor error in the notice, or an insurer’s missed deadline, does not excuse you from responding. If you believe the date or location was unreasonable, an arbitrator or a court can decide that question, and you can also file a complaint with the New York State Department of Financial Services.
What to Expect at a No-Fault IME, and How Do You Walk in Ready?
What to expect at a no-fault IME is fairly simple. The examiner will usually ask how the accident happened, what hurts, and what care you have received, and may then test your range of motion, strength, or reflexes. You will not receive treatment. These steps can help you prepare and protect your claim:
- Before the exam. Review your accident date, injuries, doctors, medications, and any earlier injuries. Bring photo ID and the exam notice.
- During the exam. Answer truthfully. Describe your good days and your bad days, without exaggerating or saying “I am fine” out of habit. Say so when a movement causes pain.
- After the exam. Write down when you arrived, how long the examiner spent with you, and which tests were done. Keep transportation receipts and wage records so you can seek reimbursement.
The no-fault regulations do not clearly say whether you may bring someone with you or record the exam. Before your appointment, ask your lawyer whether either is possible in your case.
If the examiner physically injures you during the exam, you may have a claim. In a case involving an exam ordered during a lawsuit, New York’s highest court held that the examiner owes a duty not to cause you physical harm. A claim for that injury is treated as a medical malpractice claim, and the deadline to sue is generally two years and six months.
What to do when a No-Fault IME Cutoff Letter Arrives?
A no-fault IME cutoff is a written denial based on the examiner’s findings. It may state that further care is not medically necessary, that you are able to return to work, or both. If it says you can work, your lost wage payments can stop too. The insurer’s 30-day clock to pay or deny runs from the day the exam was performed. Follow these steps to challenge benefits denied after IME New York insurers order:
- Get the report. The insurer must release it to you, your attorney, or your treating doctor upon written request.
- Bring it to your treating doctor. The report must give a factual basis and medical rationale for its conclusion. If it does, the answer must be medical evidence that directly addresses it.
- Follow your doctor’s advice on treatment. A cutoff ends payment, not your right to care, so ask whether your health plan will cover ongoing treatment.
- Choose your forum. The law gives you the option of arbitration, or you can sue the insurer in court. Talk with an attorney before you choose, because each route has its own procedures and costs.
Arbitration requires a $40 filing fee, which the insurer must return if you win all or part of your claim. You must submit your supporting documents with your request, so have your doctor’s response ready first. Overdue benefits generally earn 2 percent monthly interest, and if you win, you may also recover attorney’s fees, subject to state limits. If you wait more than 30 days after receiving a denial to file, interest generally stops building until you act.
A Cutoff Is Not a Verdict on Your Injury Lawsuit
A cutoff decides whether the carrier keeps paying benefits. It does not decide whether you can recover from the at-fault driver. An arbitration or a court decision on a medical provider’s bill does not bind your serious injury lawsuit and cannot be used as evidence of any facts.
A cutoff can still affect that lawsuit if your treatment stops, because you must prove a “serious injury” to recover for pain and suffering. For lawsuits filed on or after May 26, 2026, a temporary injury that kept you from your usual daily activities for 90 of the first 180 days no longer qualifies on that basis.
Other categories remain, including fractures, permanent consequential limitations, and significant limitations of use. Courts require objective medical proof, so consistent treatment records now matter even more. The state’s summary of the 2026 reforms lists no change to the IME rules.
One Insurance Exam Should Not Have the Last Word
Under no-fault IME New York rules, your response comes down to three things. You should attend, prepare, and challenge any cutoff with evidence from your own doctors. A missed exam can jeopardize the entire claim, but a denial can be contested, and it does not determine the outcome of your injury lawsuit.
Our lawyers fight to get medical bills and lost wages paid, so that a single appointment arranged by an insurance company does not decide what care an injured New Yorker receives. If you received an exam letter or need help challenging a denial, contact Greenspan & Greenspan Injury Lawyers for a free consultation.
Legal References Used to Inform This Page
To ensure the accuracy and clarity of this page, we referenced official legal and other resources during the content development process:
- Unitrin Advantage Ins. Co. v. Bayshore Physical Therapy, PLLC, 82 AD3d 559 (1st Dept. 2011).
- Claim Procedure, 11 N.Y.C.R.R. 65-3.5(b), (d), (e).
- Mandatory Personal Injury Protection Endorsement, 11 N.Y.C.R.R. 65-1.1(d).
- Payment or denial of claim, 11 N.Y.C.R.R. 65-3.8(a)(1), (b)(1).
- Nationwide Gen. Ins. Co. v. Gaines, 237 AD3d 411 (1st Dept. 2025).
- DFS Office of General Counsel Opinion No. 01-03-10 (Mar. 12, 2001).
- American Tr. Ins. Co. v. Martinez, 202 AD3d 526 (1st Dept. 2022).
- Follow-up requirements, 11 N.Y.C.R.R. 65-3.6(b).
- Claim procedure, 11 N.Y.C.R.R. 65-3.5(p).
- Bazakos v Lewis, 12 NY3d 631 (2009).
- Interest on overdue payments, 11 N.Y.C.R.R. 65-3.9(a), (c).
- Fair claims settlement, N.Y. Ins. Law § 5106 (2023).
- Definitions, N.Y. Ins. Law, § 5102(d) (2026).
- Initiation of optional arbitration procedures, 11 N.Y.C.R.R. 65-4.2.
